| 1939 | New England | ||
| 1940 | Amboy | Eddie Smith | P |
| 1941 | Golden | ||
| 1942 | Fullerton | Mort Cooper | P |
| 1943 | Fullerton | Johnny Niggeling | P |
| 1944 | Amboy | ||
| 1945 | Golden | ||
| 1946 | |||
| 1947 | Delaware | ||
| 1948 | Sacramento | Dick Fowler | P |
| 1949 | Suwanee | E. Joost | SS |
| 1950 | Cape Canaveral | Al Widmar | P |
| 1951 | Cape Canaveral | Early Wynn | P |
| 1952 | Long Island | Sam Rogovin | P |
| 1953 | Fullerton | Bob Lemon | P |
| 1954 | Suwanee | Lew Burdette | P |
