1939
C E Lombardi STS
1B J Mize AMD
2B J Gordon MIB
3B R Rolfe CHC
SS A Vaughan AMD
LF B Johnson MIB
CF J Dimaggio FUT
RF T Williams NEL

1940
C H Danning AMD
1B J Mize AMD
2B J Gordon MIB
3B B Lewis SER
SS J Cronin KCA
LF H Greenberg BRD
CF W Judnich KCA
RF T Williams SER

1941
C J Early FUT
1B J Mize AMD
2B J Gordon MIB
3B C Travis FUT
SS J Cronin KCA
LF C Keller FUT
CF J Dimaggio FUT
RF T Henrich GOR

1942
1B J Mize AMD
2B J Gordon MIB
3B S Hack AMD
SS J Pesky BRD
LF T Williams SDK
CF J Dimaggio FUT
RF E Slaughter FCP

1943
C W Cooper FOG
1B R York PAL
2B B Doerr FOG
3B B Elliott FOG
SS A Vaughan AMD
LF J Heath CHC
CF C Keller FUT
RF B Nicholson FOG

1944
C F Hayes SSD
1B F McCormick SDK
2B B Doerr FOG
3B B Elliott FOG
SS V Stephens SDK
LF J Lindell KCA
CF B Nicholson FOG
RF S Spence AMD

1945
C P Masi AMD
1B N Etten FOG
2B S Stirnweiss MIB
3B L Olmo SDK
SS V Stephens SDK
LF C Workman KCA
CF D Walker GOR
RF T Holmes AMD

1946
C A Seminick AMD
1B H Greenberg MIB
2B B Doerr FOG
3B W Kurowski MIB
SS J Pesky BRD
LF T Williams SDK
CF J Dimaggio FUT
RF S Spence AMD

1947
C W Cooper FOG
1B J Mize AMD
2B J Gordon MIB
3B W Kurowski MIB
SS L Appling MIB
LF R Kiner RNY
CF J Dimaggio FUT
RF T Henrich GOR

1948
C Y Berra BRD
1B S Musial BRD
2B J Gordon MIB
3B K Keltner BRD
SS L Boudreau DED
LF T Williams SDK
CF J Dimaggio FUT
RF P Mullin BRD

1949
C Y Berra BRD
1B T Henrich GOR
2B J Robinson RNY
3B B Dillinger SAR
SS V Stephens SDK
LF R Kiner RNY
CF B Thomson AMD
RF L Doby SAR

1950
C R Campanella GOR
1B W Dropo AMD
2B B Doerr CCR
3B H Thompson KCA
SS V Stephens SDK
LF S Gordon DED
CF J Dimaggio FUT
RF S Musial BRD

1951
C R Campanella GOR
1B G Hodges LIG
2B J Robinson LIG
3B B Thomson AMD
SS A Dark KCA
LF R Kiner LIG
CF S Musial BRD
RF M Minoso AMD

1952
C Y Berra BRD
1B S Musial BRD
2B J Robinson LIG
3B E Mathews SAR
SS E Joost SWM
LF R Kiner LIG
CF B Thomson AMD
RF H Sauer AMD

1953
C R Campanella PRP
1B A Rosen SWM
2B R Schoendiens SWM
3B E Mathews SAR
SS A Dark KCA
LF G Zernial BRD
CF D Snider DED
RF S Musial BRD

1954
C Y Berra BRD
1B G Hodges LIG
2B J Gilliam CCJ
3B E Mathews SAR
SS A Dark KCA
LF T Williams SDK
CF W Mays PRP
RF S Musial BRD

1955
C R Campanella PRP
1B S Musial NWE
2B N Fox SDK
3B E Mathews SAR
SS E Banks SAR
LF R Sievers PRP
CF W Mays PRP
RF A Kaline MIB